Sport Consumer Behaviors and Sport Leadership

Dr. James Jianhui Zhang

professor, University of Florida

[jamesz@hhp.ufl.edu]

 

返回

 

Dr. James J. Zhang attended Tianjin Institute of Physical Education, China, for his undergraduate study in physical education. Upon graduation in 1984, he was employed by the same institute as a lecturer in sport administration. In 1987, Dr. Zhang received a studying-aboard scholarship granted by the Chinese government and came to the U.S. He completed his master's and doctoral degrees in sport administration and measurement/evaluation at Springfield College, MA, a well-known institution with a rich history in sport and physical education. In 1993, Dr. Zhang went to the University of Houston, TX, where he was enrolled in a post-doctoral study program for one year and worked as faculty member for seven years. He came to the University of Florida in 2001 and was promoted to the academic rank of professor in 2006.

Dr. Zhang conducts applied measurement and applied studies in two areas: sport consumer behaviors and sport leadership. He adopts an integrated approach to predicting sport consumption behaviors and formulating effective marketing strategies through studying market demand and competition, socio-motivation, service quality, consumer lifestyle, and sociodemographic segmentation. He has studied sport leadership with a focus on formal and informal leadership associated with sport and recreation programs. Classical and contemporary leadership theories, such as trait, behavioral, contingency, and/or transformation, are usually used as research frameworks. He also contributes to faculty and student research using his expertise in research design, measurement, statistics, and management and marketing theories. Following the leadership theories, Dr. Zhang has been conducting the 21st CCLC Leadership Project to provide effective leadership to after school programs through integrated scientific (program evaluation), managerial (policy and compliance), and practical (technical training and assistance) procedures. The path-goal leadership theory is the primary framework that guides the project's design and conduct. He has authored or co-authored over 70 refereed research manuscripts and has made over 200 presentations in these areas. He has served on the editorial board or as a reviewer for such scholarly journals as Measurement in Physical Education and Exercise Science, Journal of Sport Management, Sport Management Review, International Journal of Sport Management, and Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport, among many others. To date, he has obtained external funding of exceeding $6 million.

Among many recognitions, Dr. Zhang is the recipient of 2005 Scholar Award of the Southern District AAHPERD, 2006 Measurement and Evaluation Council Honor Award of AAHPERD, and the University of Florida Research Foundation Endowed Professorship from 2007-2009, one of the highest recognitions of outstanding scholarship at the University of Florida. He is most proud of being a committed Gator fan, cheering for the reigning NCAA Division I football and men's basketball champions of Florida Gators. He is a season ticket holder of both teams.


Research Overview

For sport organizations, the key to achieving organizational objectives consists of being more effective than competitors in integrating marketing activities toward determining and satisfying the needs and wants of consumers in the target markets. Sport organizations are generally market-driven. Understanding the cause and channel of sport consumer behaviors is the fundamental process for designing and implementing activities that are purported for the production, pricing, promotion, and distribution of sport products and services to satisfy the needs and desires of consumers and to achieve the organizational objectives. In the meanwhile, the management process within a sport organization is also essential for the effective planning, organizing, leading, and controlling of financial and human resources in order to achieve the organization's internal (growth and job satisfaction) and external (quality product and service) objectives. Quality leadership coordinates the organization and its members, and ensures the organization to move more rapidly and successfully toward its objectives.


1. Zhang, J. J., Lam, E. T. C., Smith, D. W., Fleming, D. S., & Connaughton, D. P. (2006). Development of the Scale for Program Facilitators to assess the effectiveness of after-school achievement programs. Measurement in Physical Education and Exercise Science, 10(3), 151-167.

Establishing procedures to monitor the progress of an after school program is critical to achieving these program objectives. As a quality control procedure, evaluation is an essential part of the management process. After school programs should have a continuous evaluation component built into the design to improve program effectiveness and accountability, ensure student and parent satisfaction, and identify necessary changes. Program evaluations provide information for curriculum and activity adjustment, reallocation of funding, improvement of facilities, staff development, decision-making, and accountability. Properly conceived evaluation systems can not only provide information on student achievement, but also improve the environment in which students are engaged. The purpose of this study was to develop the Scale for Program Facilitators (SPF) to assess the effectiveness of after school achievement programs through four steps: (a) identification of a theoretical framework, (b) formulation of the initial scale, (c) test of content validity, and (d) conducting confirmatory factor analyses (CFA). A comprehensive review of literature revealed that after school programs commonly have four key objectives: (a) Scholastic Development, (b) Social Behavior, (c) Caring Environment, and (d) Personal Inspiration. The preliminary scale with 18 items was formulated by following these objectives as the theoretical framework, along with conducting a review of literature, on-site observations, interviews with program facilitators, and conducting a test of content validity by a panel of experts. Research participants (N = 2,995) were program facilitators, who were asked to use the preliminary SPF scale to evaluate the program attendees under their direct supervision. Adopting the Maximum Likelihood (ML) and the Weighted Least Squares (WLS) estimation methods in the CFA, the four-factor model was confirmed providing good fit to the data. Discussions were made in the context of the scale development and its potential application in evaluating after school programs.


2. Cianfrone, B. A., & Zhang, J. J. (2006). Differential effects of television commercials, athlete endorsements, and event sponsorships during a televised action sports event. Journal of Sport Management, 20, 321-343.

Corporations frequently question which types of sport sponsorships provide a better return on investment. Although TV commercials, venue signage, and athlete endorsements are major promotional forms that are commonly adopted by corporations, their differential effects have rarely been examined. In the sport management literature, the effectiveness of these promotional forms is widely assumed. However, there have been no true experimental studies that have established the cause-effect relationship, or differentiated among the effects of the promotional forms. Likewise, these are also pressing issues in action sports. It would be very beneficial to know whether promotions are effective in reaching Gen-Y consumers, and if so, to what extent, and which methods work best. Obtaining this information could assist the organizers of action sports events in communicating with corporations more effectively, formulating better promotional and pricing strategies, and improving their accountability for corporate investments. Additionally, information on the differential effects could help corporations make informed decisions when choosing a sponsorship package. This study examined the differential effectiveness of television commercials, athlete endorsements, venue signage, and combined promotions, as assessed by Generation Y consumers. A 2 x 4 independent-group experimental design was conducted, consisting of two experimental conditions (experimental and control) and four video footage interventions with different promotional procedures (television commercial, athlete endorsement, venue signage, and combined promotion). A total of 253 subjects were randomly assigned into the eight groups. The subjects responded to a questionnaire that measured brand awareness in terms of unaided recall, aided recall, and recognition. A factorial MANCOVA revealed that after controlling for differences in the consumption backgrounds of action sports among the subjects, all four promotional procedures effectively increased the brand awareness during a televised action sports event. Television commercials were the most effective, followed by combined promotion, athlete endorsement, and venue signage.


3. Zhang, J. J., Connaughton, D. P., & Vaughn, C. (2004). The Quality of special programs and services for NBA season ticket holders and their predictability to game consumption. International Journal of Sport Marketing and Sponsorship, 6(2), 99-116.

The impetuous for investigating service quality stemmed from trying to understand general consumer displeasure with services. Another reason for the interest in service quality was the mounting evidence indicating that providing superior service produces a competitive advantage. Managers thus became increasingly interested in improving the quality of services provided to their customers. Given the importance of attracting and retaining season ticket holders, little research has examined the quality of special programs and services designed for season ticket holders. In an effort to fill this void, a systematic research investigation appears necessary. A systematic study would provide scientific evidence and practical direction for professional sport teams to develop and implement special programs and services. In this study, examining the first research issue (i.e., satisfaction of special programs and services) would provide information on the expectations and perceptions of season ticket holders toward special programs and services, and point out general areas for improvement. The second research issue (i.e., predictability of service quality to game consumption) would provide information on the importance and relevance of special programs and services to game attendance, and highlight the areas for immediate attention by professional sport teams. This study was designed to examine the role of special programs and services for sport season ticket holders in predicting their game consumption. The following two research issues were examined: (a) satisfaction of special programs and services, and (b) predictability of service quality to game consumption. Participants (N=350) were season ticket holders of an NBA team, who responded to a questionnaire that included 6 demographic variables, 8 consumption variables, and 15 special program and service variables in two versions: importance and perception. Findings revealed that the season ticket holders deemed the special programs and services important and satisfying. Four identical factors were determined for the importance and the perception versions of the special program and service variables (Representative, Benefit, Opportunity, and Socialization), and three factors for the game consumption variables (Event Viewing, Ticket Type, and Ticket Level). Three importance and perception factors (Representative, Socialization, and Opportunity) were positively predictive of the game consumption factors. Congruence between importance and perception versions of Opportunity was positively related to Event Viewing. The findings further emphasize the importance of providing quality programs and services to season ticket holders, and pointed out specific program and service areas for improvement.


4. Zhang, J. J., Pennington-Gray, L., Connaughton, D. P., *Braunstein, J. R., *Ellis, M. H., Lam, E. T. C., Williamson, D. (2003). Understanding women's professional basketball game spectators: Sociodemographics, game consumption, and entertainment options. Sport Marketing Quarterly, 12(4), 228-243.

A comprehensive review of literature has helped to reach the following three conjectures: (a) there is a need to study the sociodemographic characteristics of spectators at women's professional basketball games, (b) there has been a general lack of investigation into the relationships between sociodemographic variables and game consumption, and (c) entertainment and leisure options as an aspect of lifestyle may directly or indirectly affect attendance. These speculations require further examination through empirical investigations. The purpose of this study was to examine the hierarchical relationships among sociodemographics, lifestyle, and level of game consumption of women's professional basketball spectators. Spectators (N = 2,048) from five regular season home games of a major WNBA team responded to a questionnaire designed to measure sociodemographics (10 items), level of spectator consumption (6 items), and lifestyle (19 items). Conducting factor analyses with principal axis extraction and oblimin rotation, one factor emerged for the level of spectator participation variables (Game Consumption) and four factors emerged for the lifestyle variables (Professional Sports, Amusement Activities, Amateur Sports, and Recreational Sports). Regression analyses and analyses of variance revealed that nearly all sociodemographic variables and two lifestyle factors (Professional Sports and Amateur Sports) were related to Game Consumption; however, hierarchical regression analyses revealed that the lifestyle factors did not mediate the relationships between sociodemographics and Game Consumption. The findings demonstrate the importance of promoting women's professional basketball games through sociodemographics, and during professional and amateur sporting events.

5. Braunstein, J. R., Zhang, J. J., Trail, G. T., Gibson, H. J. (2005). Dimensions of market demand associated with Major League Baseball Spring Training: Development of a scale. Sport Management Review, 8(3), 271-296.

The market environment of Major League Baseball's (MLB) Spring Training (ST) in Florida, USA has a number of unique characteristics including the laid-back atmosphere at the games, weather, greater accessibility to athletes, and more affordability when compared to regular season games. In addition, another important characteristic is the fact that Florida is one of the top tourism destinations in the U.S. and many of the spectators at ST games are on vacation, and as such ST is a form of event sport tourism. To effectively market ST games, sport marketers should be aware of the potential influence of these characteristics in addition to the general consumer expectations towards the core attributes of the game. However, we know little about ST spectators. Therefore, the purpose of this study was to develop a scale that measures market demand variables associated with ST games. Through a review of literature, a test of content validity, and a pilot study, the preliminary Spectator Decision Making Inventory - Spring Training (SDMI - ST) was developed that included 42 items measuring six constructs: Game Attractiveness, Game Promotion, Economic Consideration, Schedule Convenience, Vacation Activity, and Nostalgic Sentiment. Research participants (N = 465) were spectators at six ST games during spring 2004. The data set was split into two halves: one for exploration and the other for confirmation. Through exploratory and confirmatory factor analyses, and tests of internal consistency and average variance extracted, eight factors, represented by 29 items, were retained in the final SDMI - ST (Home Team, Opposing Team, Game Promotion, Economic Consideration, Schedule Convenience, Vacation Activity, Nostalgic Sentiment, and Love Baseball). Although the scale needs further development, the findings provide a framework for ST game consumption. MLB teams, practitioners, and academicians may adopt the scale to conduct research that assesses the effect the of market demand factors on ST consumers.

返回